NYY/BAL

[Brewers GM (Larry)]

This trade should not be approved as is IMO

The New York Yankees trade...

OF: Trayce Thompson PP-20 $.4M
P: Colin Rea PP-20 $.45M
P: Aaron Blair PP-20 $.4M
P: Roenis Elias 17:$.4M
C- Victor Caratini (ChC)
CI- Adam Brett Walker (Bal)
2017 Rockies 5th round FYPD

to the Baltimore Orioles for...

C: Christian Vazquez 17:$1M, 18:$1M
OF: Ryan Braun 17:$19M, 18:$19M, 19:$18M, 20:$16M, 21:$15
SP: Carlos Carrasco 17:$6.5M, 18:$8M, 19:$9M, 20:$9.5M

[Deleted]

Agreed seem pretty bad

[Deleted]

I would veto

[Giants GM (Ron)]

Veto. Not even close.

[Deleted]

The Orioles should be getting better pieces. There's just too much downside. Veto.

[Brewers GM (Larry)]

Message sent to Matt & Bob

Sorry guys league office has decide this trade is to heavy in favor of the Yankees so it's been vetoed. Please attempt to re-work the deal.

The New York Yankees trade...

OF: Trayce Thompson PP-20 $.4M
P: Colin Rea PP-20 $.45M
P: Aaron Blair PP-20 $.4M
P: Roenis Elias 17:$.4M
C- Victor Caratini (ChC)
CI- Adam Brett Walker (Bal)
2017 Rockies 5th round FYPD

to the Baltimore Orioles for...

C: Christian Vazquez 17:$1M, 18:$1M
OF: Ryan Braun 17:$19M, 18:$19M, 19:$18M, 20:$16M, 21:$15
SP: Carlos Carrasco 17:$6.5M, 18:$8M, 19:$9M, 20:$9.5M

[Brewers GM (Larry)]

Re-do is still no good for 2 studs

Orioles send

Carrasco
Braun

to the Yankees for

OF: Trayce Thompson PP-20 $.4M
P: Colin Rea PP-20 $.45M
P: Aaron Blair PP-20 $.4M
P: Henry Owens PP-20 $.4M
P: Roenis Elias 17:$.4M
C- Andrew Knapp
CI- Adam Brett Walker
2017 Rockies 5th round FYPD

[Giants GM (Ron)]

Agree

[Deleted]

Quantity over Quality. We see it way too often.

[Deleted]

New is Henry Owens, a huge fly ball pitcher with control problems. Also: Andrew Knapp, who at 25 may have a roll as a backup catcher early, with a chance to become a full-time catcher, though long-term value is hazy. Christian Vazquez gets removed, Yankees take on big salary, with questions about Braun's longevity.

Eh, it's closer. Still don't like it. Definitely quantity over quality. Would like to see Orioles receive a higher upside player in return.

[Brewers GM (Larry)]

I'm sure if the O's shopped Carrasco he would get more all by himself. We need to stop letting teams gut their rosters only to leave.

[Deleted]

I agree. That Red Sox owner we had, what was it...three years ago? He started with a roster with plenty of talent, made terrible trades left and right during the offseason, and then disappeared once the season started with an awful roster. And I warned you guys that was exactly what would happen. Obviously owners in this league aren't going to be happy when their "take advantage of" trades don't get pushed through, but we need to do what's best for the league.

[Brewers GM (Larry)]

Why did this trade get processed on Fantrax? It needs to be reversed

[Deleted]

So I guess we're letting both of those NYY/BAL trades go through? Blows my mind a bit, but I suppose at this point they're on the fringe of not being veto-worthy.

[Deleted]

I dont think the Braun trade is bad at all if you consider contracts and getting Soler who can still turn into something. The Carrasco one i haven't looked at deep enough to be honest

[Brewers GM (Larry)]

I don't like them but they are passable

[Giants GM (Ron)]

Agree with Larry.